Quirke J

False evidence from plaintiff results in dismissal of PI action.

Higgins v. Caldark Ltd [2010] IEHC 527
(High Court, Quirke J, 18 NOvember 2010)

High Court apportions liability for workplace accident as to 25% to plaintiff and 75% to defendant, but dismisses claim for damages on the grounds that the plaintiff adduced false and misleading evidence as to his post-accident earnings. (Full text.)

Personal injuries – workplace injury – coat sleeve entangled in shaft of tractor – amputation of thumb – liability – apportionment of liability between plaintiff and defendant – allegedly false and misleading evidence in plaintiff’s affidavit – s 26, More

Laycock -v- Gaughan & Ors, Medical negligence

Laycock -v- Gaughan & Ors [2011] IEHC 52 (Quirke J, 21 January 2011)

High Court dismisses plaintiff’s claim for damages for alleged medical negligence. (Click here for full text.)

Medical negligence – diagnostic laparoscopy – puncture of blood vessel – salpingectomy – ectopic pregnancy – whether plaintiff established that defendant punctured blood vessel – causation – failure to carry out blood tests.

Dunne v. National Maternity Hospital [1989] I.R. 91

Subscribe

Get every new post on this site delivered to your Inbox.

Join other subscriberss: